How Fair is Your phone?

Primary tabs

How Fair is Your phone?

How fair is your phone? Charlie Ashford says that gadget makers need to confront human rights issues in their supply chains.
tweet me:
Gadget makers need to confront human rights issues in their supply chains

Multimedia from this Release

A young tin miner on Bangka. Source: Ulet Ifansasti/Friends of the Earth

Friday, May 31, 2013 - 3:50pm


Last month, Samsung confirmed that its phones contain tin from Bangka Island, Indonesia. According to Friends of the Earth, tin mining on Bangka depends on child labour, destroys tropical forests and coral reefs, and kills an estimated 150 miners every year.

Samsung has now publicly committed to helping find a solution to the situation on Bangka. Although it is far from the only company to source tin from the island, its competitors – including Apple – have so far stayed silent.

Mobile phones contain more than thirty different kinds of minerals and metals. Given complex global supply chains, it’s almost impossible to guarantee that your phone doesn’t contain minerals from regions like Bangka and the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), where metals like tantalum, tungsten, tin and gold are mined by forced labour and help fund brutal militias.

What can companies do about it? The key is not to stop sourcing from these areas. In the DRC, where 82% of the population is considered unemployed, mining supports tens of thousands of people. Instead, companies need to map out their supply chains, and work to find industry-wide solutions. Initiatives like Solutions for Hope, a pilot initiative launched by Motorola to source conflict-free tantalum from the DRC, are a good start. Yet according to NGO Global Witness, phone makers are among companies lobbying against new US laws on supply chain due diligence.

This week, the Fairphone project began taking pre-orders. It may be starting small, but the project has big ambitions. Aiming to create a “smartphone that puts social values first”, Fairphone will start with conflict-free tantalum and tin, and is working towards sourcing conflict-free tungsten and Fairtrade-certified gold and cobalt. It also aims to pay workers a living wage, be transparent about suppliers and pricing, use recycled materials and make the phone as adaptable and recyclable as possible, perhaps eventually becoming fully “closed loop”.

Buying more stuff seems like a counter-intuitive way to reduce your impacts, especially on the environment. But Fairphone is definitely a step in the right direction, and looks likely to meet its target of 5,000 pre-orders. High-profile network partners already include Vodafone, O2/Telefónica and KPN.

Phone makers should be watching with interest.

Keywords: Innovation & Technology | Corporate Citizenship | Corporate Responsibility | Innovation & Technology | Mobile phones | Responsible Business & Employee Engagement | Samsung | cell phones | csr | fairtrade | supply chain